Project 3 of 12 - accept your stepfamily identity, and agree who belongs

Who Belongs to Our Stepfamily? - p. 2 of 2

How to Resolve Membership Conflicts

Peter K. Gerlach, MSW
Member, NSRC Experts Council

colorbar

The Web address of this two-page article is http://sfhelp.org/03/members.htm

Continued...

       The prior page reviewed what family membership conflicts are, and why they can be major re/marital and family stressors. This page examines...

  • who does belong to a typical multi-home stepfamily?  and...

  • how adults can reduce or resolve significant family-membership disputes.

  Who Does Belong to Our Stepfamily?

       To broaden your perspective in answering this question, review (a) this opinion, and (b the following premises. Fully accepting the premises may promote some confrontations among your family adults and kids, which can grow your awareness and empathy. To clarify your beliefs, rank each premise T(rue), F(alse), or ? ("I'm torn or not sure).

       
1)  Most (all?) kids and adults instinctively need to feel genuinely accepted (included) and valued in a primary group - ideally by people they know, trust, and respect. When this need is unmet, people feel abandoned, isolated, alone, lonely, and (often) anxious. The exceptions to this are adults and kids traumatized (neglected) in childhood, who developed Reactive Attachment Disorder - an inability to bond with, need, and genuinely care about some or all other people. (T  F  ?)

        2)  A stepfamily is any group which includes one or more minor or grown stepkids, and one or more adults accepting the role of part-time or full-time stepparent. Stepparents ma\y or may not have biokids of their own. Committed stepfamily partners may be in a psychological stepfamily (dating and perhaps cohabiting) or a legal one after exchanging commitment vows.  (T  F  ?)

        3)  About 90% of U.S. stepfamilies follow the divorce (vs. death) of one or both committed partners. Genetically, legally, financially, and psychologically, dead bioparents can significantly affect the relationships among kids and re/married partners and their relatives. So most stepfamilies include one or two co-parenting ex-mates (each stepchild's other bioparent). (T  F  ?)

        Fully (vs. superficially) including these adults in your stepfamily - even if they're inactive - means that...

        4)  Typical stepfamilies have three or more stepparents and bioparents, living in two or more related dwellings. Minor kids usually visit their other bioparent's household periodically or regularly. This usually tapers off in mid and late adolescence.  (T  F  ?); And...

        Premise 5)  Minor and grown kids usually include both bioparents and any genetic siblings and accessible genetic relatives as members of their post-divorce or post-death families. One or both bioparents' committing to and/or cohabiting with a new partner rarely alters this. (T  F  ?)  Is this true in your situation?

        6)  Despite major pre-divorce and post-separation co-parenting-relationship barriers, many divorced bioparents still care about the welfare of their child-conception partner for years - specially if they really bonded and had a long relationship. (T  F  ?)

        This can manifest as a "love-hate" attitude about ex-mates, specially if one or both are unrecovering survivors of low-nurturance childhoods. After their adult child divorces, grandparents can feel ambivalent or "torn" about their grandkids' "other parent" too. Ambivalence is a common sign of values differences between active personality subselves. (T  F  ?)

        7)  If a bioparent or their minor or adult child hasn't adequately mourned their many family-reorganization losses from parental separation, divorce or death, and then cohabiting; they'll often find it hard to fully accept (vs. bond with) their ex-mate's new partner, prior kids, and inlaws as full members of their legal or psychological stepfamily. (T  F  ?) Incomplete grief is one of five widespread family stressors,  which is why Project 5 is so important.

        Conversely, insecure (wounded) new stepparents will often reject their mate's ex spouse as a legitimate member of their new stepfamily. This can expand to co-parents in any of the two or more linked homes trying to reject their ex/es from legally belonging to their new stepfamily.

        Do you need a stretch break before continuing? When you're ready, compare your beliefs to these additional premises about who belongs to your stepfamily...

      Premise 8)  Bottom line - as long as there one of their kids or grandkids is alive, all three or more co-parents in their several homes linked by finances, visitations, genes, laws, dreams, needs, feelings, rituals, and history are co-equal members of their common nuclear stepfamily.

        Whether actively involved or not, each co-parent's ancestry, needs, opinions, values, wounds, stability, health, and behaviors affect other family adults and kids. Even well-mourned dead parents and grandparents have significant emotional and genetic affects on their survivors and step-relatives for many years, and so are full psychological stepfamily members. Notice your self-talk now...

        9)  Some genetic or legal relatives can reject membership in a new stepfamily, even if invited - e.g. a grandparent or bioparent may feel or say "I'm not part of their (re/married) family, no matter what you or they say!"  (T  F  ?)

        10)  It's much easier for kids to accept their new step-kin, family roles, and membership, if all their co-parents and key relatives clearly do too, without major reservation, ambivalence, blame, resentments, or shame. (T  F  ?)

        11)  As long as one or more adults or kids ignores or rejects their stepfamily identity ("No, we're just 'a regular (biological) family'"), stressful membership (loyalty) conflicts will occur.
This rejection usually results from unhealed false-self wounds + unawareness + incomplete grief + immaturity.

        The first two can be reduced, once identified and admitted. The more time that has elapsed between biofamily separation and bioparent re/wedding and/or cohabiting...

  • the more likely that significant forgivenesses and mourning progress have happened, and...

  • the lower the odds of major membership conflicts.

This is usually not true if some or many family members unrecovering Grown Wounded Children (GWCs).

        12)  "Family membership" is part of your kids' and adults' personal identity. It also affects who they seek support from in a crisis. Rejection from stepfamily membership hurts! It says "Your needs, feelings, and opinions aren't important to us - you're 1-down (inferior)." For GWCs with excessive shame and guilts, this membership rejection amplifies their feeling worthless, flawed, and unlovable.

        Bonds that unite members of a stepfamily in challenging and good times are directly proportional to the sense of belonging that has grown among all multi-generational members.

        13)  Average adults and kids are ruled by a group of interactive subselves, which can cause a behavioral double message - i.e. pretended inclusion. Wounded people with reactive Shamed, Guilty,   Responsible, and/or Good Inner Kids - and a devoted People Pleaser (we must be nice!), Worrier ("If we're rude, bad things will happen!"), and/or Inner Critic - are likely to demonstrate erratic or insincere acceptance of some stepfamily members, and (their protective Magician subself will) deny it. 

        14)  All related co-parents are primarily responsible to (a) genuinely accept their stepfamily identity,  and (b) see that inclusion/exclusion conflicts within their extended stepfamily are...

  • acknowledged, vs. denied,

  • confronted, vs. postponed, and...

  • resolved well enough, vs. argued endlessly.

Minor and grown stepkids depend on their co-parents to accept and work at this responsibility. Failure to do so inhibits healthy stepfamily bonding and biofamily-merger progress, lowers the stepfamily's nurturance level, and weakens co-parents' re/marriages.

+ + +

        Reflect: on a scale of 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree), how do you feel about these premises now? Combined, they suggest a way to decide "Who belongs to (significantly affects the roles, relationships, and nurturance-level in) our multi-home stepfamily?

  • An emotionally-committed (bonded) bioparent-stepparent couple, and...

  • All their dead and living; minor and grown; adopted, foster, and biokids; and...

  • Both bioparents and any other key caregivers of each living child and grandchild; and...

  • Any new partner of "the other bioparent/s," and their kids and active relatives; and...

  • Each relative that is psychologically, genetically, legally, or financially important to any of these three or more co-parenting adults and their minor and grown kids.

       Do you agree? If so, what does that mean in your family situation now? If you don't agree, what would it mean - specifically - to you and/or other stepfamily members if the premises above do apply to you all?

        If any of your family members significantly disagree on who belongs, what can you do?

  Options for Resolving Membership Conflicts

        Learn the definition of a stepfamily. If you're really co-committed as a couple, accept that you're in one now psychologically as long as your commitment and web of bonds exists. One of several signs that members have done this step is that they spontaneously refer to themselves as "our stepfamily."

        Learn what's real in typical stepfamilies and what that probably means for you adults and kids.

        Accept that one meaning is that mates in your stepfamily are at high risk of eventual re/divorce for five reasons, and need to co-commit to some version of these 12 safeguard Projects - ideally starting before exchanging commitment vows. Partners who are significantly ruled by false selves (wounded) will ignore this, despite convincing personal and social evidence.

        Work at the first seven projects together patiently and thoroughly, ideally starting in courtship. This includes doing thorough checks for false-self wounds and blocked grief, and building effective problem-solving skills together. It also includes (a) mapping your multi-generational stepfamily, (b) discussing the maps with all concerned, and (c) identifying all inner and mutual step-identity and membership conflicts without blame.

        Co-parents model talking openly about membership (inclusion/exclusion) conflicts ("Pat, you and I disagree on who comprises our stepfamily, don't we?"), and encourage your kids and kin to do so. These are normal divorced-family and stepfamily stressors: no one is bad or wrong when they happen! Talking together honestly (including feelings and needs ) is the first step in resolving these stressors.

        Divorcing bioparents...

  • accept co-responsibility for identifying and resolving unhealed stressors with (co-parenting) ex mates and key kin, and...

  • work at that to protect you all from probable re/divorce.

Ideally, begin well before re/wedding/s. If you don't, membership and related (loyalty) conflicts and relationship triangles will recur and inexorably reduce your stepfamily's nurturance level. 

        A key question to research honestly is "What would it mean to me if I fully accepted __________ as a full member of our stepfamily?" Often the core reasons are prospective losses of prized hopes ("We'll never be the 'regular family' I long for"), illusion ("Stepfamilies aren't that different,") or protective false-self denials ("Maybe I re/married into the wrong group of people!").

        Co-parents adopt attitudes of long-range patience and realistic optimism. Typical multi-home stepfamilies are exceptionally complex. They often take well over four years to merge and stabilize after re/marriage (vs. cohabiting). Really resolving divisive step-identity and membership conflicts takes time!

        Read, discuss, and apply these options for dealing with step-rejections by a mate or a relative (including an ex mate). If you've done your homework (above), these options should help reduce your stressors, over time. They presume your Self (capital "S") is leading your other subselves!

        If you still have trouble, consider temporarily using qualified, stepfamily-aware professional help in resolving identity, membership (inclusion), and any related loyalty conflicts and triangles until you get the hang of it.

        Finally, co-parents help each other stay balanced enough - i.e. don't over-focus on these conflicts unless you feel you're in a crisis.

           Pause now, and notice what you're thinking and feeling - without judgment. Notice if some "voice" within you is coaching you to get going on, ignore, scorn, or avoid options like those above. Recall why you started reading this article, and say out loud what you need. Option: dig down honestly to test whether that's a symptom of your need, or the real thing.

    Next
    : continue Project 3 by learning how to use genograms (family maps) to help identify and resolve stepfamily membership (inclusion/exclusion) conflicts.

    + + +

    This article was very helpful   somewhat helpful   not helpful   

    <<  Prior page  /  Add to favorites  /  Print page  /  Email this article's address  >>

colorbar

 home  /  site overview  /  directory  /  site map  /  Q&A  /  quizzes  /  solutions  /  site search  /  glossary

  research  /  free course  /  guidebooks  NEW  forums resources  /  feedback  and/or  subscribe  * copyright info

Updated  August 19, 2008