Project 4 of 12 - change stepfamily myths into realistic expectations

What's Normal In a Stepfamily?

 Realities 1 to 10 (of 60)

By Peter K. Gerlach, MSW
Member, NSRC Expert Council

colorbar

  • home > site overview > site map, directory, or search > Project-4 links, Q&A, Solutions article, or other page > here

The Web address of this 8-page article is http://sfhelp.org/04/myths.htm

        Clicking links below will open a full window or an informational popup, so please turn off your browser's popup blocker or allow popups from this nonprofit Web site.

        This is one of over 150 articles focused on healing psychological wounds,  building high-nurtur-ance family relationships, breaking the [wounds + unawareness] cycle, and preventing divorce. This introduction describes the Web site's purpose and the best ways to use its resources. Each article is part of a mosaic of ideas, so the more you read, the more sense they'll all make.

        These articles augment, vs. replace, other qualified professional help. The "/" in re/marriage and re/divorce notes that it may be a stepparent's first union. "Co-parents" means both bioparents, or any of the three or more related stepparents and bioparents co-managing a multi-home nuclear stepfamily. 

        Before continuing, reflect: why are you reading this - what do you need?

button  Directions

        Read these five pages after you've thoughtfully reviewed the three-page Web article on 60 Common Stepfamily Myths. The bracketed [  ] items below refer to these myths (unrealistic expectations). Several myths may be lumped together in one reality below.

        These items summarize what I've come to believe is real in typical U.S. stepfamilies, after 27 years' clinical work with over 1,000 typical re/married couples and co-parents. There are exceptions to these baseline stepfamily realities, so what follows is a general profile, not cosmic law.

available Spring 2003guidebook for co-parent Projects 8-12        Links below lead to more detail on key topics. Note these practical guidebooks that integrate the articles in this Web site. They're part of a series of volumes family adults and lay and professional supporters.

        These books exist to combat the current U.S. divorce epidemic which blights the lives of millions of kids and adults. This epidemic is somber evidence of the unseen [wounds + unawareness] cycle which is relentlessly spreading and weakening our society.

      The purpose of Project 4 and these eight pages is to help your adults form realistic expecta-tions and goals for your unique multi-home stepfamily. The alternative is your unconsciously acting on a set of biofamily-based beliefs that will probably frustrate and stress all your adults and kids over time.

         If any of your adults feel skeptical about some of these realities, check them out with veteran (i.e. re/married five+ years) stepparents and bioparents ("co-parents"), and with other stepfamily authors.

        From my experience as a stepson, stepfather, and stepfamily researcher, therapist, and educator since 1979, every one of these 60 expectations is partly or completely untrue in average multi-home stepfamilies! They are potentially-harmful myths.

button Here's What's (Usually) REAL...

[ Myths 1 - 3 ]  A stepfamily is a multi-generational group of related adults and kids in which one or more adults accepts the role of  part-time or full-time stepparent for their mate's biochild/ren. Any single mother or father seriously dating and/or living with a new partner forms a stepfamily. Most post-divorce stepfamilies include one or more co-parenting ex-mates and their relatives. Blended families are stepfamilies in which both mates have living and/or dead biochildren from prior unions.

        Typical stepfamilies are like intact biofamilies in some ways, and also differ structurally and dynamically in over 60 ways. This is why accepting your identity as a stepfamily [vs. "No, we're just a (bio)family"] is essential.

        Most adults are unaware of many of these differences and what they all mean. Family Projects 3 and 4 in this divorce-prevention Web site provide the education typical stepfamily adults need in order to understand these differences.        

        Typical post-divorce stepfamilies are governed by legal documents like divorce and property-settle-ment decrees, and parenting agreements that define child custody, support, visitation, and other parenting responsibilities. These documents usually don't define the child-raising responsibilities (roles) of stepparents, which can cause significant confusion and conflict.

       Re/marrying couples whose kids are grown and independent still form a stepfamily. These couples bypass many stresses around minor kids: e.g. child visitation, support, and custody conflicts. Middle-aged re/marriers still encounter serious stressors like stepfamily unawareness, unhealed childhood trauma, incomplete grief, and divisive loyalty, membership, and values conflicts around kids, grandkids, wills and bequests, names, holidays, family priorities, and cherished traditions.

[ Myth 4 ]  An intact nuclear biofamily (parents and dependent kids) normally lives in one home. Typical nuclear stepfamilies (co-parents and visiting and custodial minor kids) live in two or more homes bound together for years by child visitations, legal agreements and responsibilities, genes, history, finances, special events, and deep emotions.

        The only stepfamily that lives in one home is one where all biokids or non-custodial bioparents are dead or uninvolved. Even then, there are usually emotional and other ties with the absent people, living ex in-laws, and with stepkin living in other homes.

[ Myths 5 - 7 ]  Because they are adults and kids living and growing together, sharing concerns with work and school, health, pets, bills, chores, church, friends, etc., stepfamilies are just like average intact ("traditional") biofamilies.

        Paradoxically, they also differ in structure, tasks, and norms in up to 70 ways! These differences usually combine to cause unexpected confusion, frustrations, guilts, and conflicts for years. They often render "common sense" biofamily rules ineffective or even harmful to relationships and stepfamily bonding.

        Some key differences: unlike intact biofamilies, typical nuclear stepfamilies:

  • Live in two to three related co-parenting homes, not one;

  • Always include (a) one or more dead or absent bioparents (ex spouses), and (b) some of their blood relatives. Thus, most stepfamilies have three or more co-parents, six or more co-grandparents, and many other genetic and legal relatives. This means...

  • Typical multi-generational stepfamilies have 60-100+ people and hundreds of relationships. This usually causes many complex conflicts over roles, rules, priorities, values, names, holidays, inclusions, traditions, money, and loyalties. And typical stepfamilies...

  • Are always founded on two sets of major losses: (a) divorce or death, and (b) co-commitment,  cohabiting, and complex biofamily mergers. All three generations in the three or more merging biofamilies need to grieve these losses well, over time.

        And typical stepfamilies...

  • Have up to 30 family roles (e.g. stepdaughter, half-brother, step-niece), compared to 15 roles in typical biofamilies. There are no accepted social conventions for these new roles, so they typically cause confusion and frustration in and between linked homes for years, until a family-wide consensus evolves on how to "do" them.

  • Typical stepfamily members must deal with social isolation, major misunderstandings, and negative biases. They...

  • Must learn, accept, and master at least 12 complex Projects over many years in order to guard their members against five major hazards. Six of these alien Projects have no equivalent in average intact biofamilies. Typical co-parents and their kids must attempt this with little preparation or social support. And American stepfamilies...

  • Probably divorce more frequently, legally or psychologically, than typical biofamilies.

       So: typical multi-home stepfamilies are usually as different from intact biofamilies as 747 jets are from your family car. Therefore, all stepfamily adults - including ex mates and their kin - should study stepfamily basics, regardless of prior biofamily experience. Note that growing up as a stepchild is usually not adequate preparation for being an effective stepmom or stepdad.

       Over time, all parenting households evolve hundreds of rules (shoulds and oughts), about child discipline, finances, holidays, names, privacy, money, pets, home chores, grooming, health, worship, etc. Many of these rules are unspoken. 

        Because average stepfamilies are so different, some traditional biofamily rules about cohabiting and  parenting can cause conflict rather than order (e.g. see realities 14 -24). Other common biofamily rules about who's in charge of the home, hygiene, privacy, interpersonal respect, clear communications, honesty, nutrition, and the like are still relevant and applicable. The challenge over time is to learn which biofamily rules are relevant and which aren't.

       Steppeople often become stressed from trying to force "normal" biofamily priorities on their new households. For example, pushing stepkids to accept, respect, and like (or love) their new step-relatives quickly because "kids should respect and obey their elders" can cause major resentments, guilts, and frustrations.

        So: all typical stepfamily adults - including co-grandparents, co-uncles, and co-aunts - should...
  • be alert for old biofamily shoulds, musts, and oughts that don't work well in and between their linked stepfamily homes, and...

  • be motivated to negotiate new rules that do work well. 

        All step-adults can benefit from studying the experience and advice of stepfamily veterans and qualified professionals. Adults' prior biofamily experience is often not a reliable guide for stepfamily success. New-partners' love is frequently not enough!

[ Myth 8 ] Co-parents' relatives and friends often mistakenly expect the new household and kin to feel and act pretty much like (their image of) a traditional biofamily. They also may secretly or openly disapprove of prior divorces and/or the parent's new union. Therefore, friends and relatives may be startlingly unempathic and critical, or offer unrealistic or inappropriate (i.e. biofamily) suggestions when co-parents run into unexpected role and relationship problems. See reality 56, too.

[ Myth 9 ]   Divorce and/or spouse death end the primacy and legal and religious contracts of a marriage. They may not end the psychological bond between the former partners, specially if they raised kids together. This is common if one mate didn't want the divorce, and/or if either of them is blocked in mourning their losses.

        Re/weddings, cohabiting, "ours-child" conceptions, stepchild adoptions, graduations, and other family events can trigger strong emotional and perhaps sexual feelings in divorcing co-parents well after their separating. "Endless" ex-mate hostility, and personal and legal battles over child custody, financial support, and visitation, or constant demands for personal attention or assistance, all suggest a former relationship that is still psychologically alive. Some other symptoms:

  • Ceaselessly rehashing the good (or bad) old biofamily or marital times, or not reminiscing at all;

  • Forbidding their child to mention their new stepparent or call them "stepmother" or "stepfather";

  • Steadily avoiding appropriate social or dating contacts;

  • Instructing their minor child/ren not to obey or respect their new stepparent or step-relatives;

  • Rigidly refusing to accept their identity as a stepfamily member;

  • Refusing to talk about (or with) their ex mate, and/or refusing to join them in appropriate co-parenting responsibilities;

  • Staying emotionally enmeshed (a subjective judgment) with their ex in-laws; and ...

  • Vehemently denying they're doing these things, or justifying or minimizing them.

       Note also that grandparents, relatives, and in-laws can deny the reality of their child's or kin's divorce, and show similar symptoms. So can dependent and grown biokids. A key issue is whether all relatives affected by a prior death or divorce and bioparental re/marriage have grieved their losses (broken bonds) well enough. See Realities [29-30].

[ Myth 10 ] My experience since 1985 suggests that over ~80% of average U.S. divorced parents and stepfamily couples were unintentionally deprived in their early years of vital nurturances like unconditional love, respect, and affirmations; healthy individuality; self confidence and self esteem; appropriate touching; encouragement to feel and express all emotions without guilt or shame; and trust that others would effectively care about and help with their problems.

       From long habit, adult survivors of low-nurturance childhoods often protectively deny to themselves and others the deep inner pain, shame, emptiness, confusion, sadness, rage, and fears - or numbness - that grew from their deprivations. The protective false self causing these denials can seriously interfere with achieving healthy, lasting, committed relationships. During courtship, false-self wounds are often well hidden behind attractive masks.

        There is growing evidence that if not self-motivated to admit and reduce their wounds, typical single parents unconsciously choose and re-choose wounded partners. They also risk unintentionally wounding their children as their unaware ancestors did. Lay and clinical literature since the early '80s refer to wounded survivors as "Adult Children" (of "toxic parents" and childhood "dysfunction").

       Common symptoms of significant childhood neglect are repeated relationship troubles including avoidance, divorce, affairs, codependence (compulsive over-concern with the feelings and welfare of key others); chronic "mood disorders," and addicitions to activities (like work, spending, or helping others) and/or to substances, including common sugars, fats ("comfort foods"), and mood-altering drugs.

        Coupled with (a) unawareness and (b) the complex merger-adjustment tasks of stepfamily life, the false-self wounds in two or more co-parents can relentlessly hinder bonding, grieving, and teamwork, and promote eventual re/divorce. I suspect that unseen false-self wounding and related ignorance are probably the two most powerful roots of most American social problems, including rampant divorce. Few clinical professionals (including clergy) seem to recognize this so far. Many appear to be unaware of their own significant wounds and what they mean.

      So: all courting and committed partners should assess their and their mate's childhoods for neglect and false-self wounds, and seek informed help as required. Effective help is increasingly available, and can help reduce wounds and related unawareness over time. In case you think "Not me! Not my partner!" note that the normal false-self strategies for coping with these painful inner wounds are repression (emotional numbing) and denial (reality distortion).

        Pause, breathe, and reflect - what are you aware of now?

    Continue Project 4 with stepfamily realities 11-21 of 60. Do you need a break first?
     

<<  Prior page  /  Add to favorites  /  Print page  /  Email this myth-series' address  >>

colorbar

 home  /  site overview  /  directory  /  site map  /  Q&A  /  quizzes  /  solutions  /  site search  /  glossary

  research  /  free course  /  guidebooks  NEW