Project 9 of 12 toward high-nurturance families and relationships

Minimize common conflicts from
moving in together (cohabiting)

Make "their home" our home, over time

by Peter K. Gerlach, MSW
Member NSRC Experts Council

 colorbar

  • home > site overview > site map, directory, or search > Q&A, Solutions article, or other page > here

  The Web address of this article is http://sfhelp.org/09/cohabit.htm

        Clicking links below will open a full window or an informational popup, so please turn off your browser's popup blocker or allow popups from this nonprofit Web site.

        This is one of over 150 articles focused on building high-nurturance family relationships and preventing divorce. This introduction describes the Web site's purpose and the best ways to use its resources. Each article is part of a mosaic of ideas, so the more you read, the more sense they'll all make. These articles augment, vs. replace, other qualified professional help.

        Before continuing, reflect: why are you reading this - what do you need?

+ + +

        This Project-9 article is for family adults and kids who have been - or may be - affected by two courting partners combining households before, after, or instead of legal marriage. Their cohabiting will cause losses and changes throughout two or more multi-generational biofamilies - specially if one or both partners have kids and ex mates from prior unions. For interesting perspective, first scan this brief research summary on unmarried (cohabiting) families.

        The article presents:

Perspective

        Some courting or newly-re/wedded partners move in to live in their mate's existing home.. Either or both partners may have custodial or visiting (or adult) kids from former unions, and one or more living or dead ex mates. Other couples and any custodial kids move into a dwelling that's new to them all - an "ours" home. The first option usually causes more problems for members of their three or more  related biofamilies. 

        After a move-in, each co-parent (including ex mates), and child has a mix of different adjustment needs to fill as everyone strives to evolve and stabilize their routines, roles, relationships, and spaces. Combining  lifestyles, belongings, and dwellings is inevitably complex. Unless both partners have formed a new stepfamily before, even diligent move-together planning can't avoid significant cohabiting conflicts.

        Household and family merger-stress is proportional to...

how ready each affected adult and child was for the dwelling and life-routine losses and changes,

who's needs controlled the decision to cohabit and the timing,

how effective all affected adults are at communicating, problem-solving, grieving, co-parenting, and managing change; and...

how aware the bioparents and stepparents are about what they and their kids are getting into. Cohabiting after the death of a former spouse (vs. divorce) may cause fewer problems, but their intensity and complexity can still be daunting for everyone.

        Courting co-parents can significantly reduce everyone's adjustment stresses by taking the time to learn some key things first, surveying everyone's needs honestly, and then evolving a thoughtful cohabiting plan together. Get the most from this article by first reading...

  • the basic premises underlying the this non-profit Web site;

  • the key ingredients of a healthy relationship and a high-nurturance family,

  • these stepfamily basics and implications,

  • the five reasons most divorcing family and stepfamily relationships are extra stressful, 

  • the common causes of most stepfamily role and relationship problems,

  • 12 ways co-parents can evolve a high-nurturance stepfamily,

  • these overviews of "right-time" factors, and 16 groups of things cohabiters must merge.

        This Web site proposes that (a) needs are physical, psychological, or spiritual discomforts; (b) problems are unfilled needs; (c) most problems have _ surface symptoms, and _ underlying primary needs. It also proposes that most people (like you?) are unaware of these realities, and often focus on trying to satisfy the surface needs (symptoms) rather than the primary needs that cause them. This often results in the problems "coming back," and mounting frustration among people affected by the problem/s. Does this ever happen to your family members?

        With these ideas in mind, pause, reflect, and say out loud your version of common problems (needs) that typical couples and their relatives encounter when the couple cohabits. Then compare your answer to this:

Common Surface Cohabiting Stressors

        For perspective, recall the last time you changed dwellings. You probably had to...

  • decide who was responsible for what task, pick a date to move, and notify key people.

  • _ clean and _ reorganize the space you're moving into, and _ arrange for vehicle parking, as needed;

  • _ sort belongings and _ dispose of some; _ get containers and _ pack the rest, _ arrange transport, and _ unpack,

  • cope with any moving problems, like breaking an appliance or heirloom, lifting heavy things up stairs, or finding that something large wouldn't fit through a doorway.

  • _ adjust furnishings and decor in the new dwelling, and _ arrange for water, gas, electricity, telephone, banking, prescriptions, and other services as needed;

  • let key people and creditors know your _ new address, _ phone number/s, and _ other relevant details,

  • learn the current boundaries, rituals, preferences, and routines of the people living in your new space, if any; and...

  • _ familiarize yourself with the new neighborhood and community, and _ settle on a new commuting routine to work or school.

        This is daunting enough without kids and perhaps pets in one or both dwellings. Add one or more ex mates and three or more sets of relatives who are affected by the dwelling change, and a big new category of "moving-in problems" appears: "stepfamily conflicts about changing dwellings, roles, finances, and locales."

        The surface problems in this category can include things like these: one or more people disagree over...

moving at all, and/or moving at this time;

the morality of couples living together before marriage - specially if minor kids are involved;

which people get which bedrooms and closets, and who rooms or sleeps with whom;

who gives up their duplicate furnishings, like beds, appliances, couches, desks, plates, utensils, and picture, and what they do with them;

who pays for what in the new dwelling, and when;

vehicle usage, parking, insurance, and maintenance;

decisions about buying food, cooking, eating, and cleaning up afterwards;

decoration preferences and tasks - painting, wall-papering, drapes, shades, rugs, lighting,  furnishings,

comfort clashes over temperature, noise levels, allergies, mattresses, privacies, bathroom and TV priorities, sexuality and nudity, etc;

chores and household responsibilities, curfews (if any), pet care, baby sitting and/or day care scheduling, school transport,

names and titles - who calls who what?

child-raising values (manners, grooming, appearance, hygiene, drugs), styles (permissive vs. strict), and...

who makes the major living decisions - who's in charge of the combined dwelling?

        Every courting or re/married couple and their kids and relatives will have a unique mix of "standard" and "stepfamily" surface problems like these. When the conflicts that arise from these are "significant" and/or "don't go away," There are usually up to...


Six Primary Cohabiting Problems

        Most (all?) common cohabiting surface problems have one or more of these six underlying causes. Option: use this as a move-planning checklist with your other co-parents and child/ren:

        1) One or both partners don't fully accept their stepfamily identity or what it means - so they have unrealistic expectations about roles and relationships in their new stepfamily home and with ex mates and relatives. Implication: often, partners will not believe these problems apply to them and their kids until they experience them so any cohabiting (merger plans) are superficial.

        2) One or more adults or kids hasn't grieved prior family-adjustment losses well enough, and isn't ready to cohabit and form new stepfamily relationships. Being forced to move too soon causes secondary problems like hostility, "sabotage," withdrawals, and "a bad attitude." The core problems here are that average co-parents don't know...

  • good-grief basics,

  • how and why to assess for incomplete morning,

  • how to "free up" blocked mourning, and...

  • how to (a) evolve a healthy family grieving policy together, and (b) how to use it effectively;

        3)  One partner is ambivalent or "uneasy" about living together, but agrees to do so to avoid conflict. A companion problem may be one partner intensely longing to live together, and pushing the cohabiting process despite c/overt resistance from other people. A common variation is both partners are ready to live together, but one or more ex mates, kids, and/or relatives are strongly opposed. Significant adult unawareness and wounds usually cause all of these.

        Another common primary cohabiting (and re/marital) problem is...

        4)  Co-parents don't know effective-communication basics and how and when to use these skills. In addition, before moving in together, typical co-parents need to learn...

  • how to distinguish surface needs from underlying primary needs; and... 

  • what each co-parent's core priorities are, how compatible they are, and how to resolve significant incompatibilities effectively; and...

  • the difference between problem-solving and other popular options like arguing, demanding, threatening, avoiding, explaining, hinting, defocusing, manipulating, lecturing, and blaming; and co-parents need to know...

  • how to spot and effectively resolve family conflicts over...

    • values (e.g. about money; child discipline, visitations, and custody; cleanliness, leisure, chores, worship, health, education, etc.);

    • stepfamily identity,   membership  (inclusion/exclusion), loyalties (priorities), roles, and titles (are you Alicia, John's daughter, or my stepdaughter?); and conflicting...

    • communication _ needs and _ styles (e.g. arguing, defending, explaining, demanding, or avoiding vs. problem-solving)

        And before co-parents move in together, they and related ex mates and active co-grandparents should learn...

         5)  What typical minor kids need to (a) develop toward healthy independence, and to (b) adjust successfully to major family changes like parental separation, early-stepfamily relationships, and cohabiting. Once they know these two sets of needs, co-parents can assess each child's status on them, and then discuss how moving in together will help or hinder each child's progress with them.

        Co-parents guided by their true Selves (capital "S") are then also able to draft co-parent "job descriptions" - i.e. outlines of which co-parent is responsible for filling which need of whose child? Two important focal areas to discuss before cohabiting are child discipline and child-related expenses, including insurances. These discussions must include kids' "other parent/s" (ex mates') needs, motivations, and resources. Family Project 10 and this practical guidebook focus on evolving an effective co-parenting team over time.

        Finally, before committing to cohabit, partners should...

        6)  Learn healthy-grieving basics, and draft a healthy family good-grief policy as a base for helping each adult and child mourn the losses (broken bonds) they (you) all will experience from cohabiting and merging these things.

        Partners who survived a low-nurturance childhood risk not knowing they habitually mute or repress their emotions - which will inhibit healthy grief. They also are likely to have unconsciously learned family policies (values and practices) which will inhibit their children from mourning their losses (broken bonds) well. Family Project 5 offers good-grief basics, and articles on detecting and releasing blocked grief. Option: take this good-grief quiz to learn what you (need to) know about effective three-level grieving.  

        These are not trivial topics, so partners do well to spend many weeks or months assessing how these primary issues affect their situation before they draft a move-together plan and start the complex biofamily merger process. When they (you) do,... 

Expect Two Stepfamily-unique Challenges

        True story: after 16 years' marriage and conceiving three children together, Nancy chose to divorce Mark (not their real names). A year and a half after the legal process ended, Mark remarried a long-time family friend who had also divorced the prior year. Mark's kids knew Sharon and her ex and two kids well, and had mixed reactions to the re/marriage. The couple decided that Sharon would move into Mark's home with her mid-teen daughter. They (and Nancy) knew little about stepfamilies and the primary problems above.

        Some weeks after Sharon and her daughter had moved in, Mark's oldest daughter Stephanie  shocked them all, one evening by raging at Sharon "Get out of my mother's kitchen! You don't belong here!" They learned later that Stephanie's outburst was partially motivated by her mother's (Nancy's) simmering resentments at Mark and her former friend for her moving into "her" house.

        It took months for everyone to (a) "calm down" from this unexpected incident, (b) relax "us vs. them" polarities, and (c) resume shifting their former friendships into new stepfamily roles. This incident probably stemmed from Mark and Sharon's being lulled by their long friendship, not seeing themselves as a stepfamily, and therefore not learning how important each of the issues above were to all of them - including Nancy.

        Mark's daughter had dramatically illuminated the second of two common cohabiting challenges:

1) people moving into one partner's existing home feeling guilty like aliens and invaders, and...

2) one or more of the resident kids or visiting kids feeling resentful at being "invaded" - specially if they hadn't been consulted or listened to (respected) about the proposed cohabiting.

I'm not sure whether Sharon and her daughter felt like aliens in Mark's home, or if so, how stressful that was. They may or may not have known themselves.

        Wounded, unaware partners who choose to cohabit with the wrong people, for the wrong reasons, at the wrong time often underrate or don't expect these two special stressors. They're apt to deny, avoid, repress, joke (or fight) about, or minimize related problems as they occur.

Options

        If you and your marvelous partner are likely to combine your dwellings and lifestyles in the foreseeable future, here are some stress-prevention options based on the above. My core advice is this: commit to helping each other with co-parent safeguard Projects 1-7 over at least 18 months (more is better) after you "turn serious," before you consider cohabiting. The guidebook for these vital family Projects is Stepfamily Courtship (Xlibris.com, 2002)

         Make a point of talking with stepfamily couples who are re/married (vs. dating) five or more years. Option: try out several of the many stepfamily "chat rooms" or "forums" on the Web. Your goal is to learn the pros and cons of cohabiting with kids from people who have done it. Don't expect to find stepfamilies that are structured like yours - and know that typical stepfamilies face common basic problems like those above despite their uniquenesses.

        Note that significantly- wounded stepfamily partners are likely to unconsciously minimize or exag-gerate (distort) their cohabiting problems and/or not know their kids' problems. See this for a quick behavioral way to estimate significant false-self wounds.

        Patiently discuss and strengthen your awareness of stepfamily identites, membership, values, and loyalty conflicts, and relationship triangles; and evolve a trial-and-error way to effectively handle each one. Be assured you will experience them over and over again - even if you haven't yet. Resolving them will depend on your co-parents' knowledge + your communication skills + your true Selves usually leading your other subselves (personalities).

        Consider using the three sets of Project- 7self-evaluation worksheets. They're designed to help courting couples make three right (complex) re/marital choices - and can also help you make three right cohabiting choices before formal re/commitments.

        Ponder this British research summary which found that unmarried families were more apt to break up than married families. Human nature transcends political and geographic boundaries...

Recap

        Stepfamily partners and kids combining dwellings and life-styles (cohabiting) often creates a mosaic of unexpected and alien confusions and conflicts. This article summarizes common surface (secondary) cohabiting problems, and hilights six primary factors that cause them.

        If partners each genuinely accept their stepfamily identity  and what it means, they'll be more apt to believe these six problems are worth resolving before they start calling movers and buying change-of-address cards.

        Pause, breathe, and recall why you read this article. Did you get what you needed? If so, what do you need now? If not - what do you need? Who's answering these questions - your wise resident true Self, or "someone else"?

+ + +

This article was very helpful  somewhat helpful  not helpful  

<<  Prior page  /  Add to favorites  /  Print page  /  Email this article's address  >>

colorbar

 home  /  site overview  /  directory  /  site map  /  Q&A  /