Break the [wounds + unawareness] cycle and guard your descendents

Better Alternatives to Legal Orders
of Restraint and Protection

p. 2 of 2

By Peter K. Gerlach, MSW

colorbar.gif

  • home > site overview > site map, directory, or search > Q&A, Solutions article, or other page > here

The Web address of this two-page article is http://sfhelp.org/10/protection.htm.

Continued from page 1...

Options If You're Accused

        In case you're feeling your victimized and without options, consider these choices:

        Listening to your own voice saying your thoughts, feelings, and needs out loud can help you clarify your feelings and needs. Try getting quiet, reflect, and say out loud (a) how you feel about being accused and legally constrained, and (b) how you're reacting to the implied and legal accusations about you and the legal constraints forced on you.

        That might sound like "I feel resentful, hurt, and angry; and I'm (a) obsessing about how unfair this is, (b) blaming my accuser for all of this trouble, and (c) avoiding conversation and contact with my accuser as much as possible. Your feelings are reliable indicators of what your ruling subselves need in this situation.

        Are your attitudes and reactions to the court order/s increasing or decreasing the stresses you and any affected kids and relatives feel? If you say "increasing," who do you believe is causing that?

Option: Learn Who's Running Your Life

       The biggest single cause of your half of your current relationship (and legal) problems may be that you are controlled by a false self without knowing it. Read this example with an open mind. Then...

  • learn about your "inner family" of personality subselves,

  • study Project 1 with an open mind, and then...

  • assess yourself honestly for significant false-self wounds.

If you find any, commit to reducing these wounds over time, with informed support. If your protective subselves minimize, postpone, or ignore this keystone option, (a) this article will probably be of little help to you and any kids you care about, and (b) your conflicts, weariness, and despair will escalate. 

Option: Accept Your Responsibility for Half the Problem

        Face the inexorable reality that as long as your ruling subselves focus on blaming your accuser and others rather than accepting that "We both are causing our problems and I need to reduce my half"...

  • your problems with your accuser will recur or increase - specially if legal force and intervention is involved; and...

  • any dependent kids are developing a protective false self and related psychological wounds day after day because of your and your accuser's unawareness + wounds + attitudes + behaviors. In middle and old age, you each will inevitably face the pain of having allowed this to happen - or you each risk living in denial and shortening your life by trying to deny your co-parental responsibility.

Option: Identify Your Needs

        Try saying out loud (a) what you need now in this difficult situation, specifically. There are probably several things - e.g. "I'd feel better if _____, _____, and ____ ." Then say honestly (b) what and/or who you feel is in the way of your filling these needs now. If you didn't identify yourself as a major block to filling your needs, you're probably unaware (a) that a well-meaning false self is skewing your perceptions and causing your reactions, and (b) of your options for empowering your true Self to take charge and make win-win decisions.

Option: Assess Your Attitude/s

        Try saying out loud the key adjectives you that feel describe your accuser. If you hear things like "S/He is dishonest, disrespectful, self-centered, irrational, stupid, controlling, illogical, childish, immature, immoral, unfair, irresponsible, abusive, aggressive,..."  that suggests you (a) are wounded and (b) unaware, just like the other person. It also suggests that without your knowing it, these disparaging attitudes have caused your past and recent behavior toward your accuser to send inflammatory "I'm 1-up (superior)" messages to her or him - which are surely promoting your conflict.

        As long as your ruling subselves insist on blaming your accuser for your problems (vs. saying "I'm half the problem"), s/he will feel...

  • unfairly blamed, attacked, discounted (disrespected), and misunderstood;

  • hurt, frustrated, defensive, and angry; and s/he will then...

  • blame you for your current conflict - specially if s/he's often dominated by a reactive, defensive, shame-based false self. 

Until you both decide to change it, this interactive behavior-cycle will create a self-stoking circular process of attack, defend, and counterattack that can last for decades and significantly distract all of you from enjoying your lives and fulfilling your missions on Earth.

        If you are consistently guided by your true Self, self-aware, and knowledgeable, you're more apt to describe your accuser compassionately as needy, wounded, and ignorant (lacking information, not stupid). Can you imagine adopting those attitudes? If you did, what would change between you and him or her? What if s/he became more aware and adopted the same attitudes about you?

Option: Notice Your Time-focus

       Assess honestly "Am I mostly focused on the past, the present, or the long-term future?" If you're often focused on the past, (a) that's more evidence you're ruled by a false self, and (b) those subselves are probably focused on short-term stress relief rather than working to preventing recurring family or relationship stress in future years. Be alert for your subselves over-focusing on short-term goals like...

  • punishing your accuser, and/or getting even (revenge),

  • proving (to someone) the accusations are unfounded. malicious, or stupid; and...

  • needing important others to see how wrong your accuser was/is and how you've been unfairly victimized, and...

  • using legal force (e.g. an aggressive attorney) to defend yourself and attack or inflict pain on your accuser.

       Both weary, pessimistic, stressed co-parents mentioned at the beginning of this article were unaware of being chronically ruled by shame-based subselves which vehemently opposed (a) admitting "I am half of our problems," and (b) refocusing from endlessly rehashing the past and blaming the ex mate and her or his judgmental family, to courageously accepting self-responsibility for personal growth and change in the present.

Option: See Your Situation as a Family Problem

        Narrow-visioned false selves and biased supporters will insist that your stress is a personal problem. That belief relentlessly promotes a harmful win/lose attitude in all of you - e.g. seeing yourself as the "1-down" victim, and your accuser and any supporters as the 1-up enemy. The immutable reality is "Our combat stresses all our family members." Option: read this two-page summary of a family system (like yours) for perspective, and return here. 

Suggestions

  • Try to capture the spirit of these premises and options, rather than seeing them as a rigid cookbook of things you and your accuser must do. The main themes are:

    • you both are wounded and unaware, and share joint responsibility for causing and reducing your current stresses; and...

    • using legal force will I always add long-term stress to your subselves and family.

    The moral is - do everything you can before invoking the court to force resolution to that which you wounded, unaware people are unable to do for yourselves so far.

  • Choose self-responsibility for the relevant premises and options in this article without saying "Ok, if my accuser will too." That's a seductive way that protective false-selves try to avoid self-responsibility and (unjustified) painful guilts and shame. Lose-lose. 

  • Review your accuser's options, and decide honestly whether each of them applies equally to you;

  • Avoid the urge to file countercharges against or otherwise punish our accuser. Doing so prolongs your conflict. Put energy into these options and suggestions instead.

  • View your situation as an opportunity to learn about yourself, your accuser, and unseen options, rather than as an unfair attack on you.

  • Consider asking your accuser to study and discuss this article with you as teammates, vs. opponents - specially if you have minor children depending on you both.

  • If you feel you must hire an attorney, avoid hiring one who has a win/lose attitude and wants to disparage and counterattack your accuser - even if your accuser hires an aggressive uninformed lawyer intent on winning  (so you "lose"). If kids are involved, seek an attorney who views your family is her or his client, not just you. If you're in a stepfamily, use these criteria as a guide to selecting an aware attorney. Approaching legal combat from a win/lose perspective guarantees that all your family member suffer persistent stress and pain long run. The best long-term shared attitude is "How can we both get enough of what we need here?"

       Pause, stretch and notice with interest what your subselves are thinking and feeling. Are you guided by your Self now, or other subselves? After deciding, recall why you're reading this article. Have your perceptions and goals shifted?

        Kids, new partners, and some relatives are usually affected by a legal battle between ex mates. This usually causes a complex web of interactive values, membership, role, and loyalty conflicts, and associated relationship triangles in and between your co-parenting homes. If your partner is involved in legal combat, there are a number of things you can do to minimize these stressors, keep your needs and boundaries clear, and preserve your serenity and primary relationship/s.

If You're the Partner of the Accuser or Defendant...

         Though many variables make your situation unique, some generalities probably apply: you seek...

  • short and long-term harmony in and between your co-parenting homes;

  • to preserve and strengthen your primary relationship;

  • to protect any dependent kids from significant stress;

  • to end the current conflict/s in and between your homes permanently;

  • Your instinct is to support your partner against his or her ex; And you...
     

  • want the chance to contribute, rather than be a passive bystander;

  • have your own view of what causes the conflict/s, which may or may not agree with your partner's perception;

  • may often feel torn about various family role and relationship issues, and be unclear on what you should do about them - specially if you have minor kids of your own; and...

  • you and your partner may agree or not on whether you should be an active participant in resolving the current conflict/s or a passive observer.

Options

        The bad news is that your home and family is burdened with a web of major conflicts. The good news is that you and the combatants have many options to help all of you reduce them. For example, you can...

        Clarify and validate your personal rights as a unique, dignified, worthy person. Then use this powerful "dig down" technique to identify your primary needs relative to the ex-mates' combat and its effects on all of you. Then use assertion, empathic- listening, and problem-solving skills to fill your and others' needs.       

        Adopt a long-range attitude (e.g. the next 20 years), and respectfully suggest your partner and her or his ex mate do the same. Rationale: focusing only on short-term relief will probably cause the underlying unmet needs to keep recurring and stressing you all, over time.

        Clarify your current life priorities. If you have trouble doing so, and/or you don't rank your integrity and wholistic health first and your primary relationship second, you're probably dominated by a well-meaning false self. If so, that will contribute to many personal, marital, and family stresses. Using the concepts, options, and resources in Project 1, assess yourself for false-self wounds, and commit to reducing any you find.

        Empathically assess your partner and her or his ex mate for significant false-self wounds. If you conclude one or both are often ruled by a false self, urge your partner (and the ex mate, if practical) to read and apply the options here.

        Learn about values and loyalty conflicts, and associated relationship triangles. Then assess how these are contributing to the conflicts between your partner and her or his ex (and others in your family?). If either person is unaware of - or minimizes - these three stressors and their impacts, urge him or her to (a) learn about them, and (b) work together to reduce them for everyone's short and long-term sakes. This will be hard or impossible if either person (a) is controlled by a protective false self, and (b) doesn't know or want to use the seven communication skills that Project 2 provides for all of you.

        If there are minor kids involved in the ex-mate's combat, (a) study and apply this to each minor child, and (b) urge your partner and his or her ex to do the same. Steadily encourage each of them to see the current conflict as a family stressor, rather than a personal dispute. Use this to help clarify your family "job" (co-parenting responsibilities).

        Read these ideas about intra-family legal battles with an open mind., If they make sense to you, apply them to your situation, and urge the combatants to do the same.

        If you believe that someone's past or current addiction is fueling the combat, learn more about addiction, its family causes and effects, and what your options are. Follow the link for perspective and resources. True addictions are a symptom of the real problems: low-nurturance environments + inner pain + personal and family unawareness. Yes, addictions cause (secondary) problems of their own, too.

        Become more aware of the communication process among your involved adults. Often how conflicted people assert their opinions, perceptions, and needs becomes the problem. Develop the communication skills of awareness and metatalk, and encourage the combatants to do the same. Option: see this article  to promote more effective communication among you all - and ask the conflicted adults to do the same.

        Avoid scorning or criticizing your partner's ex mate, regardless of her or his hostile actions. Such "1-up" attitudes are sure to add to everyone's stress, including kids'. A better alternative is to see him or her as highly wounded and unaware, while enforcing your boundaries firmly, with dignity (self respect).

        If your partner is prone to impulsive angry outbursts, threats, name-calling, swearing, insulting, and phone hang-ups with her or his ex, see that as a symptom of half the problem: a disabled true Self. Filing for legal restraint and protection indicates that the filer (a) feels s/he and/or a child is unsafe, and/or (b) s/he is misperceiving the accused person's intents and/or actions. Both are signs of major false-self wounds and a low-nurturance environment.

+ + +

        These are representative options for stepparents and other relatives affected by legal orders of restraint and protection - there are other choices too.

        Pause and reflect - why did you read this? How are you feeling about your options now?

       

Recap

        A significant minority of American divorced-families and stepfamilies are stressed by a co-parent filing for legal protection or restraint against an ex mate or other intrusive adult. Filing, granting, and enforcing such legal orders always (a) leaves the primary problems unsolved, and (b) adds new sources of hostility, disrespect, and distrust to prior (unresolved) disputes). Occasionally, such orders are truly justified to preserve an adult's or child's safety short term. Often there are much more effective options available to all involved adults than invoking legal force and intervention.

        A major premise here is that filing for legal restraint and protection is a symptom of a family-wide problem, not just one person being dangerously out of control. Focusing only on the accused-person's behavior and the threatened person's well-being and safety will usually miss the underlying primary family problems that are causing the conflicts: false-self wounds, ineffective communication, and unawareness of effective ways to identify and fill each person's personal and relationship needs.

       Based on 27 years' clinical experience with combative ex mates using the (Illinois) judicial system to resolve their problems, this two-page article (a) offers perspective on this, (b) outlines practical alternatives to legal force for the person who files, (c) options for the accused person, and (d) options for other affected adults, like stepparents or close relatives. This supplements articles on avoiding and resolving disputes over legal parenting agreements, and options for family-court attorneys and judges.

Related articles:

  • 11 common causes of most divorced-family and stepfamily surface problems

  • Avoiding and resolving disputes over legal parenting agreements

  • Why using legal force to resolve family disputes is usually lose-lose-lose, long term

  • An overview of Project 10 - build an effective co-parenting team together

  • Typical co-parent barriers, and links to solution-options

  • Suggestions for choosing an effective stepfamily counselor

  • Perspective on how to evaluate stepfamily advice and books

  • Common questions co-parents should ask - and links to answers and resources

  • Guidebooks for co-parents, based on the ideas in this nonprofit divorce-prevention Web site

+ + +

This article was very helpful  somewhat helpful  not helpful  

<<  Prior page  /  Add to favorites  /  Print page  /  Email this article's address  >>

colorbar

 home  /  site overview  /  directory  /  site map  /  Q&A  /  quizzes  /  solutions  /  site search  /  glossary

  research  /  free course  /  guidebooks  NEW  forums resources  /  feedback  and/or  subscribe  * copyright info

Created September 27, 2008