Break the [wounds + unawareness] cycle and guard your descendents

Basic Perspective on Typical
Stepparent-Stepchild Relationships

by Peter K. Gerlach, MSW
Member NSRC Experts Council

colorbar.gif (1095 bytes)

The Web address of this article is http://sfhelp.org/Rx/spsc/basics.htm

        Clicking links below will open a full window or an informational popup, so please turn off your browser's popup blocker or allow popups from this nonprofit Web site.

        This is one of over 150 articles focused on building high-nurturance family relationships and preventing divorce. This introduction describes the Web site's purpose and the best ways to use its resources. Each article is part of a mosaic of ideas, so the more you read, the more sense they'll all make.

        These articles augment, vs. replace, other qualified professional help. The "/" in re/marriage and re/divorce notes that it may be a stepparent's first union. "Co-parents" means both bioparents, or any of the three or more related stepparents and bioparents co-managing a multi-home nuclear stepfamily. 

        Before continuing, reflect: why are you reading this - what do you need?

+ + +

        This is the first of a series of articles on solving common problems between stepkids, stepparents, and other family members. Many of the ideas in this series also apply to divorcing bioparents and their children. In reading these articles, keep in mind that "problems with stepkids" are always part of a larger mix of concurrent role and relationship problems in and between the network of homes that comprise any stepfamily system.

        This article provides (a) basic premises about understanding and resolving most "stepparent-stepchild problems," and (b) general suggestions about effective stepparenting based on these premises. 

To get the most from this article and series, first read...

  • five factors that stress typical stepfamily marriages, and the common problems they cause,

  • this  introduction to normal personality subselves (like yours) - slides or text

  • the pervasive [wounds + unawareness] cycle that burdens most families,

  • traits of a high-nurturance (functional) family

  • this perspective on eight stages of normal personal growth

  • the ingredients of a healthy relationship

  • these ideas on effective stepparenting - slides or text

  • these vital questions and answers about stepparenting and stepkids;

  • these frameworks for analyzing and resolving typical relationship problems; and...

  • this research summary.

        Before reading further, check to see whether your true Self is guiding your personality now. If not, other well-meaning subselves (a "false self") may hinder your learning from this article.

If you're in a stepfamily crisis and seek a quick fix, I respectfully suggest that you seek help elsewhere. Relationship-building takes time! I write that as a veteran stepfather, stepson, step-brother, and step-grandson, and a stepfamily therapist with 27 years' experience.

        I also suggest you look elsewhere if you believe that you won't have to change something you value to fill your needs. You are probably a significant part of any "stepparenting problem." If you're willing to discover and improve your part, read on! 

        Let's start with some...

Foundations

        See if you agree with these basic premises: A = Agree, D = Disagree, and ? = "I'm not sure," or "It depends on ____" Your version of these will determine what stepfamily role and relationship problems you have, and how effective you are at permanently resolving them.

        1)  A stepparent is an adult who (a) chooses a single parent as their primary partner, and (b) wants to - and/or is expected to - accept responsibility for co-nurturing their partner's child/ren (stepchildren) from a prior relationship. Stepparent is a role, not a person. (A  D  ?)

        2) Common role problems occur when an adult or child...

  • is unclear what they're responsible for, to whom;

  • doesn't like or want an assigned role (like stepchild)

  • feels unable to perform their role adequately, by their and/or someone else's standards

  • feels overwhelmed by concurrent roles (e.g. stepmother + biomother + mate + daughter + sibling + employee + neighbor + friend + pet owner + home co-manager)

  • has unrealistic expectations and standards about role performance (e.g. "I must love my stepchild!"), and when an adult or stepchild...

  • disagrees with other key people (e.g. a spouse, ex mate, or parent) on what their reciprocal roles entail, and/or how they should be performed  (A  D  ?)

        3)  A relationship exists when the presence and/or behavior of one person has a "significant" effect on another person. Relationships range from nurturing (need-fulfilling) to toxic (need-blocking). They can be mutually-chosen, ambivalent, or forced by "circumstances" - like dating, re/marriage, and/or cohabiting.

        Forced relationships are more apt to have significant problems (unmet needs). Relationships among stepparents, stepkids, and ex mates are often forced when a single bioparent and a new primary partner commit to each other. (A  D  ?)

        4)  Relationship problems occur when the personality and behaviors of one person cause significant discomfort - needs - in another person. Two common sources of significant stepfamily-relationship discomfort are...

  • one or more adults or kids reject their stepfamily identity ("No, we're not a stepfamily") and/or what that identity means; and...

  • one or more stepfamily members are unaware of stepfamily norms, and have unrealistic expectations about how the alien roles of stepparent and stepchild should be "performed."  (A  D  ?)

        More stepparent-stepchild foundation premises...

        5) Solving role and relationship problems requires identifying and filling primary (vs. surface) needs. As long as co-parents focus on surface needs, the primary needs will keep recurring in various forms. The learnable skill of digging down helps to discern current primary needs. (A  D  ?)

      6) The personality of every normal adult and child is composed of semi-independent subselves, like the players in an orchestra or sports team. In any relationship and situation, they range from focused and harmonious to disorganized and conflicted.  (A  D  ?)

        7)  Subselves can have role or relationship problems with each other and with other people - e.g. some subselves may feel compassion for a wounded stepchild, and others may feel disinterest, irritation, and/or scorn. This causes feelings of "ambivalence," confusion, and double messages. (A  D  ?) 

        8)  Most relationship and role problems have three parts: (a) conflicts among your subselves, (b) conflicts among the other person's subselves, and (c) conflicts between your groups of personality subselves. Lasting resolutions require solving all three of these. (A  D  ?)

        9) Typical co-parents  and supporters aren't aware of stepkids' many concurrent developmental and family-adjustment needs (discomforts). The co-parents have their own sets of needs. Until adults (a) identify these different needs clearly, and (b) agree who's responsible for filling each of them, attempts to resolve stepfamily role and relationship problems often don't work.  (A  D  ?)

        10) Conflicts (clashing needs, perceptions, priorities, and values) are inevitable in any human group. Expecting or striving for a conflict-free home and stepfamily will inevitably raise personal and family-member frustration, anxiety, and doubts. A better goal is co-parents evolving effective strategies to resolve inevitable role and relationship problems. (A  D  ?)

        11) To help fill your adults' and kids' needs, your co-parents need to develop effective communication skills among your (a) subselves and (b) family members. Otherwise, stepparent-stepchild "problems" will be caused or amplified by how family members communicate. Co-parent Projects 1 and 2 provide effective ways to help each other grow these skills. (A  D  ?)

        Premise 10Effective communication and problem-solving depends on each person (a) being guided by their true Self and (b) feeling respected enough by themselves and the other person/s (like your stepchild/ren). Co-parents are responsible for maintaining both factors. (A  D  ?)

        11)  Filling primary needs (problem solving) requires change. First-order change fills only surface needs, and usually means a protective false self  is in control. Second-order (core-attitude) change satisfies primary needs. Diets that don't keep pounds off and other addiction relapses (including nicotine) signal first-order changes. So do stepparent-stepchild problems that keep recurring. (A  D  ?)

      12) Typical dependent stepkids in newly-divorcing and new stepfamilies instinctively need to test for (a) co-parental priorities (loyalties) and (b) personal security in their stepfamily ["Is this (step)family going to break up, too?"]. Unless all your co-parents and supporters accept this necessary testing, you may mis-label stepkids' behavior as rebellion, defiance, selfishness, and "acting out." That increases kids' insecurities, and may prolong or escalate their testing. (A  D  ?)

        13) Stepkids who "reject" (don't bond with) a stepparent and/or stepsiblings and stepkin may be...

  • significantly wounded from early neglect, and/or...

  • still grieving major losses from early childhood + biofamily divorce or death + bioparent re/marriage and cohabiting.

Adults controlled by false selves often can't mourn well, or show their kids how to do so. (A  D  ?)  See Project 5.  

        14)  Every relationship is significantly affected by...

  • each person's beliefs and attitudes, and...

  • how aware of them they are.

These depend on who guides each personality - the resident true Self or other subselves (a "false self"). Implication: preventing and resolving stepparent-stepchild problems starts with all co-parents intentionally reducing significant false-self wounds and empowering their Selves (capital "S") to be steadily in charge of their personalities. (A  D  ?) See Project 1.

        Premise 15)  Most (all?) "stepparent-stepchild problems" involve all active adult caregivers, not just the co-parent and child. Ignoring the needs, attitudes, values, and behaviors of other stepfamily adults (e.g. ex mates) and stepsiblings significantly raises the odds that such problems will persist or escalate. That will inevitably stress co-parents' primary relationships. Restated: "stepparent-stepchild problems" are really nuclear-stepfamily system problems. (A  D ?)

        16)  Co-parent disinterest in - or ambivalence about - these premises suggests (a) they are significantly wounded and unaware, (b) unwise primary-relationship commitments, and (c) significant risk of unintentionally promoting a low-nurturance home and family environment. (A  D  ?)

        Pause and reflect - what are you thinking and feeling? Do you agree with most or all of these foundation premises? If not, are you clear on what you do believe? Think of the reasons you began reading this - has anything changed?

        What follows builds on the premises above. Use these options like a buffet - choose what's useful, and leave the rest...
 

General Stepparenting Suggestions

         Adult patience, curiosity, humility, willingness to experiment and change, and interest in learning are major assets here. Do those describe you and other family adults now?

        Though all stepparent-stepchild relationships and problems are unique, there are some common principles that can raise your odds of evolving mutually-satisfying relationships with each minor or adult stepchild, with some limitations. Option: edit these to suit your situation, and post them where you can see them easily.

        A)  Maintain a long-term outlook - e.g. the next 15-20 years - as you work to resolve local role and relationship problems. If you don't yet have a clear goal of what you want your stepfamily to achieve across those years, invest time with your other co-parents in negotiating a meaningful family mission statement. See Project 6.

        B)  Periodically (or with major problems) check your (a) co-parents' acceptance of your stepfamily identity, and then (b) your stepfamily role and relationship expectations. In particular, avoid the trap of expecting you and your stepchild to love each other.

        Also review and discuss your key attitudes with your other co-parents. Ambivalence, vagueness, and/or co-parent disagreements over these promote stepfamily role and relationship problems in and  between your stepkids' homes! See this article and Projects 3 and 4.

        C)  Acknowledge that a powerful way to avoid and resolve many stepparent-stepchild problems is to...

  • get clear on and live by your adult priorities, and then...

  • work patiently to build as much co-parental teamwork as current limitations allow.

Often, stepparent-stepchild problems are symptoms of unresolved barriers (stressors) among related caregivers. See these articles.

        D)  Work to agree with your other co-parents what...

  • each stepchild's developmental and family-adjustment needs are, and...

  • which adults are best suited and motivated to help each child fill their mix of needs.

Use this as a foundation for resolving local stepparent-stepchild problems. Option: use this Project-10 article and worksheet as resources.

        E)  Help each other evolve fluency with these seven communication skills, and use them to evolve effective strategies to recognize and resolve stepfamily membership, identity, loyalty, and values conflicts, and associated relationship triangles. As a foundation for all of these, help each other get clear about the difference between problem-solving and these popular (ineffective) alternatives. Experiment with these tips and phrases. See Project 2.

        F)  Be alert for