Project 10 of 12  - grow a high-nurturance family together

Q&A about Healthy
Family
Relationships
p. 1 of 2

By Peter K. Gerlach, MSW

colorbar.gif

  • home > site overview > directory or site map > Solutions article or other pageQ&A index (relationships) > here

The Web address of this two-page article is http://sfhelp.org/qa/relationship-q.htm

        Links in the questions below lead to answers here, in a new browser window, or in a summary popup - so please turn off your browser's popup blocker or accept popups from this nonprofit site. The answers here are meant to augment, not replace, other competent counsel.  

        This is one of a series of Q&A articles for lay adults and family professionals. The series exists because of widespread ignorance (lack of knowledge) of seven vital topics. Ignorance + unawareness promote personal, marital, and family stress, and possible psychological or legal divorce.

        All adults want healthy, satisfying family (and other) relationships for their and their kids' sakes. The questions and answers below focus on key things adults need to know to attain that prize.

        These Q&A items aim to raise your awareness, not preach absolute truths. The items apply to relationships between personality subselves (your inner family) as well as to you and other people.

        To get the most from these Q&A items, first...

        Choose an undistracted time and place to study these items, and consider journaling about any reactions you have. Decide if your true Self is guiding your personality before you read this. If not, try to free her or him to lead, or lower your expectations of what you may learn here.

        Questions below are (a) about all relationships, and (b) about typical stepfamily relationships.

 
  Questions you should ask about
relationships

1)  I already know enough about family relationships. Why should I read this?

2)  When does "a relationship" exist between two people?

3)  What is a "functional" or "healthy" relationship? A pseudo relationship? A toxic
    
relationship?

4)  What are the essential ingredients for a satisfying (functional) relationship?

5)  Why are some relationships more satisfying and enduring than others?

6)  What's the difference between co/dependent, interdependent, and independent      relationships, and why do I need to know the difference?

7)  What is a family? A family system?  A high-nurturance ("functional") family system?

8)  What's different between my family relationships and other ones?

9)  What's needed to repair a relationship cutoff?

10)  How can I avoid or resolve having to choose between two or more people I care about?

11)  I have few or no real friendships and seldom enjoy socializing. Is something wrong?

12)  What is codependence (relationship addiction), and how can I tell if someone has that
      condition? If they do, what are my and their options?

13)  What is enmeshment, and why should our family adults care about it?

14)  What is enabling, and how can our family adults avoid and/or reduce it?

15)  Can toxic (unhealthy) relationships be improved? Yes, within limits

16)  Is there a best way to analyze and solve typical relationship "problems"? Yes! (Follow        the links)

17)  How can I improve my communication outcomes in key adult and child relationships?
 

  Questions You Should Ask about Post-divorce and Stepfamily Relationships

        Achieving mutually-satisfying relationships is specially challenging in typical multi-home divorcing families and stepfamilies. In addition to the general questions above, divorcing, courting, and committed co-parents and their relatives and supporters should ask...

18)  What's different about roles and relationships in typical divorcing families and
       stepfamilies, compared to those in intact (bio)families?

19)  What is effective co-parenting after parental separation and divorce?

20)  How can conflicted divorcing parents improve their relationship?

21)  Should typical stepfamily members expect to love each other like (healthy) genetic
       relatives do? NO.

22)  What are the most common problems between adults in average divorcing families and
       stepfamilies, and what causes them?

23)  Why are many stepfamily relationships significantly stressful, and what can reduce
       such stress?

24)  I'm less interested in nurturing a certain stepfamily relationship than the other person is,        and I feel guilty. What are my options?

25)  Some members of my stepfamily seem cool and distant to me, despite my friendship
       overtures. What are my options?

        For more perspective, see (a) these Q&A articles on courtship, remarriage, ex mates, stepparenting, stepkids, and stepsiblings; and (b) these solutions to common surface stepfamily-relationship problems. 

If you don't see your question here, please ask!

colorbar.gif

top
 

Q1)  Why should I read this?  From decades of experience (vs. study), you already know a lot about interpersonal relationships. Do you know enough? Paradoxically, until you study relationship concepts, you can't answer that. Start by deciding if your true Self is guiding your personality now. If not, expect skewed results below. Then compare your definition of "relationship" to Q2 below after you finish reading this. 

        Four ways to gauge whether you should study these Q&A items are...

  • Reflect: on a scale of one (I avoid relationships, and most that I have cause me significant stress) to ten (I never have trouble making and enjoying relationships with adults and kids), I rate myself as a ___;

  • Decide how successful you are at admitting and resolving relationship problems (rarely > sometimes > always successful);

  • Take this instructive quiz with an open mind, and see what you learn about yourself; and....

  • If you're nurturing someone's minor kids, decide how comfortable and competent you are at teaching them how to form, evaluate, and maintain satisfying relationships: low > moderate > high.

        If you're in a divorcing family or a stepfamily (or may be), also read the answers to Q16 - Q23. Those family relationships and roles are complex and usually prone to special problems.

top

Q2)  When does "a relationship" exist between two people?  It exists when the presence or absence and behavior of each person has a "significant" mental-emotional-spiritual-physical affect on the other - face-to-face and apart, now and over time. Significant is a subjective judgment.

       The importance of a relationship is proportional to (a) how often each person is affected by the other, and (b) the priority of what each person needs (Q4) from the other. For example, do you have a relationship with your favorite TV newsperson? The mayor of Philadelphia? Your postmaster? Your doctor? Your garbage collector? Your favorite author/ess? Buddhists, mystics, and some philosophers say all living things "relate" because we all affect each other. Do you agree?

top

Q3)  What is a functional or healthy relationship? A pseudo relationship? A toxic relationship? Premise - relationships exist to fill a mix of each person's local and long-term needs. So relationships vary between "very nurturing" (need-satisfying) and "very toxic" (stressful).

        This is also true with each relationship among the dynamic subselves that make up your personality. The nurturance level (low > moderate > high) of a relationship or group is determined by how well each person feels their needs are satisfied over time (Q4 below).

        In a pseudo relationship, one or both people pretend to feel interest, concern, and caring which they don't really feel. Usually this happens when person B has something that person A needs and values, and may withhold; or person A fears something about person B. Some sales people, politicians, abused kids, criminals, and employees maintain pseudo relationships with other people..

        Pseudo relationships can also occur because the person's subselves need to deny something painful ("I really don't love my mate.") or they feel guilty and/or ashamed to reveal something that will cause one or both of them discomfort. ("I am often really bored by you.")

top

Q4)  What are essential ingredients to a satisfying (functional) relationship? - There are many opinions on this. What do you feel the most important factors are? My research and experience suggest these are...

  • personal awareness and knowledge; and...

  • each partner's true Self directing their group of personality subselves, and...

  • the shared ability to bond (form genuine emotional-spiritual attachments), and...

  • a genuine shared mutual-respect attitude, and...

  • effective communication skills, and...

  • mutually-compatible interests, lifestyles, and values.

        Premise: to build or improve relationships among your subselves, family members, and other people, start by defining your version of these key relationship ingredients. Then take responsibility for learning how to acquire them with important adults and kids. Tailor this proposal to widen your perspective and promote shared discussion.

top

 

Q5)  Why are some relationships more satisfying and enduring than others?  Think of the most satisfying relationships across your life. Now think of several that were notably "unsatisfying." What makes the difference? Premise: relationships exist to fill each partners' unique mix of primary needs.

        Two pivotal factors in most social and inner-family relationships are whether each partner or subself  (a) values their respective needs equally (feels genuine mutual respect), and (b) stays equally aware of their and their partner's needs in calm times and conflicts.

        Both factors depend on whether each person is guided by their true Self or not, locally and over time. Can you tell when your Self (capital "S") is guiding your other subselves? If your Self isn't leading, do you know who is?

top
 

Q6)  What's the difference between a co-dependent. interdependent, and independent relation- ship, and why do I need to know this difference?

        Try saying your definition of "dependence" out loud. If you accept that all relationships exist to fill  a set of personal needs, then a "dependent' relationship is one where one partner needs help from another to fill some key needs they feel they can't fill otherwise. By definition, all child-adult relationships are dependent, until kids become self-sufficient.

        A co-dependent relationship is an extreme case of this, where a person's dominant false self loses their personal identity and boundaries, and compulsively focuses on the welfare, needs, and behaviors of  another person. Many people feel that the psychological condition (vs. "disease") of co-dependence is a form of relationship addiction. See this and this for more perspective and options.

        An interdependent relationship exists when both people (a) are usually guided by their resident true Selves, and (b) genuinely feel something like "I want to (vs. need to) be with you, and I can live well enough without you if I have to."

        An independent relationship exists when one or both people (a) want to spend time and energy together, and (b don't really depend on (need) their partner to fill key personal needs. This is common when one or both partners are significantly wounded and are unable to form genuine bonds with other people or living things.

        Most relationships are a blend of these three types, depending on personalities and situations. Over time, one type may predominate. Relationship satisfaction depends partly on how each partner's preferred type matches the other

         Adults and older kids need to understand and use this distinction to help decide if (a) they and/or a partner have significant wounds and/or unawarenesses, and (b) whether a relationship-type (values) clash  is promoting significant relationship "problems" - e.g. "I need to feel needed by you, often, and you don't really need me for much (so I'm frustrated, disappointed, and dissatisfied)."

top
 

Q8)  What's different between my family relationships and other ones? First, are you clear enough on what a family is? If you're not sure, review this and return.

        Do you agree that your family (ideally) fills key primary needs better than any other available group of people? Ideally...

  • your childhood family provided most of your daily and developmental needs during your early years, compared to schools, athletic teams, gangs, friends, neighborhoods, and/or churches; and...

  • your current family relationships provide love, loyalty, reliable belonging, acceptance, shelter and support (i.e. a refuge) in normal and tough times.

       In non-emergencies, most genuinely bonded (minimally-wounded) people rank family relationships higher than others because losing or damaging them carries significantly more pain and risk. Family relationships and shared experiences and ancestries shape our personal identity - so losing such relationships may confuse or blur our identity for a time.

        We're trained by instinct, tradition, the media, and childhood experience to prize and expect more comfort and support from genetic (biological) and perhaps legal family members (in laws). Does this match your experience?

        Reflect: try naming each person whom you include in your current family. Does your network of relationships with them feel like a reliable, nurturing refuge or something else?

top
 

Q9)  What's needed to repair a relationship cutoff? A cut-off occurs when an adult or child decides to avoid or break off contact with another person. This usually happens when the initiator...

  • is ruled by a false self and doesn't know it or what to do about it; and/or...

  • isn't aware of effective communication skills; and/or...

  • disrespects and distrusts the other person and/or their behaviors; and...

  • expects face-to-face or other contacts will surely cause unendurable inner pain; and...

  • feels powerless to improve their relationship contacts, and sees no benefit in trying any more.

        Other factors can add to these, like...

  • feeling overwhelmed by life stressors;

  • having distorted perceptions or information about the other person/s; and/or...

  • fearing some major loss if they don't break contact with the other person/s.

        Study the options in this article for ways to reduce or end significant relationship cutoffs.

top 
 

Q10)  How can I avoid or resolve having to choose between two or more people I care about? When needs, values, and perceptions clash, a member of any family or group must "choose sides with" (ally, agree with, or support) one or more members over others. This is specially common in typical divorcing families and stepfamilies.

        When mates encounter these loyalty conflicts and can find no mutually-acceptable compromises, their odds for long-term relationship harmony increase if they...

  • put their personal integrities and health first,

  • their primary relationship second, and...

  • all else third, except in emergencies.

        Mates' and family members' harmony increase if they want to learn how to spot and unhook from loyalty conflicts and associated relationship triangles. This is more